You are deciding between Bagel AI and Reforge Insights. Both help product teams deal with fragmented feedback. Both claim to turn chaos into clarity. But they take very different approaches. One focuses on identifying patterns. The other focuses on tying those patterns to revenue. This piece breaks it down in plain terms (and show why Bagel AI is the top-rated Reforge Insights Alternative)
Switch to Bagel AI
What they were built to fix
Reforge Insights was built to clean up messy qualitative feedback. It tries to answer, “What are users saying?”
Bagel AI was built to reduce misalignment between product and GTM. It tries to answer, “Which user issues affect the business?”
Reforge addresses volume and voice. Bagel connects feedback to outcomes.
Side-by-side comparison
| Area | Reforge Insights | Bagel AI |
| Feedback collection | Yes | Yes |
| Theming and clustering | Yes (general AI) | Yes (company-trained AI) |
| Sentiment analysis | Yes | Yes (when linked to business risk) |
| Revenue attribution | No | Yes (ARR, churn risk, expansion potential) |
| Tool integrations | Slack, Jira, Notion | Salesforce, Jira, Slack, Zendesk, Intercom |
| Primary use cases | UX improvements, onboarding issues, high-volume feedback | Roadmap prioritization, expansion blockers, churn detection |
| Custom AI model per customer | No | Yes |
| Decision support | General themes | Quantified opportunities and risks |
What Reforge does well
It pulls feedback from lots of places and turns it into readable trends. It helps teams spot repeat problems. It is good at sentiment. Its Slack bot is fast. If you run a product-led org with lots of user input and want to know what is trending, it gets the job done.
Reforge is more useful in B2C and PLG settings, where customer volume is high and product decisions are driven by patterns across a broad base.
What Bagel AI does differently
Bagel does not stop at patterns. It shows which feedback matters most to the business. Not just what is broken, but what it is costing you.
It ties feedback to:
- Open deals
- Renewal timelines
- Account tier
- Revenue exposure
It shows what to build and when, based on real customer value.
Its AI model is trained on your data. Your CRM structure. Your pipeline stages. Your support tagging logic. That level of specificity matters when the next feature is the difference between closing or losing $1.5M in ARR.
Bagel works across B2B, PLG, and B2C. It supports product teams who need to work with CS, Sales, and RevOps in real time.
An example, two outcomes
A dozen users complain about a missing SSO login option.
Reforge:
- Flags it as a common onboarding issue
- Suggests it is impacting perception of ease-of-use
Bagel:
- Identifies three enterprise customers with SSO requests tied to upcoming renewals
- Quantifies the risk: $1.2M in ARR within 60 days
- Pushes the issue into Jira and alerts Sales and CS
One points out the trend. The other turns it into a business decision.
Questions to ask before choosing
1. What kind of feedback matters most to you?
If you are dealing with usability issues, Reforge might be enough. If you are prioritizing roadmap items based on revenue and retention, Bagel is the better fit.
2. Who needs access to the insights?
Reforge serves researchers and product ops. Bagel serves PMs, Sales Engineers, CS, Product Marketing, and RevOps.
3. What is the cost of delay?
Reforge shows what users dislike. Bagel shows what is blocking deals. If your product needs to prove its contribution to revenue, you need that connection.
4. Do you need AI trained on your business, or is generic classification sufficient?
Bagel builds a model around your data. Reforge uses broader theming. One is custom. The other is fast and lightweight.
If you are choosing between the two
| Use case | Reforge Insights | Bagel AI |
| High-volume user feedback | âś“ | âś“ |
| B2C or PLG with simple product decisions | âś“ | âś“ |
| GTM-aligned prioritization | âś“ | |
| Forecasting impact of roadmap items | âś“ | |
| Revenue-linked product planning | âś“ | |
| Coordinating across PM, Sales, CS | âś“ | |
| Handling broad UX sentiment | âś“ |
Closing thought
Reforge is a feedback aggregator. Bagel is a decision engine. Both are useful. Which one you need depends on what you are trying to solve.
If your roadmap is expected to move metrics, not just sentiment, Bagel is the one designed for that job.
